009 Society Members Forum

Modelling => Locomotives => Topic started by: Steve Lewis on February 21, 2017, 09:18

Title: Lynton & Barnstaple 2-6-2T from Heljan
Post by: Steve Lewis on February 21, 2017, 09:18
Members  who  are  awaiting  the  arrival  of  the  L&B 2-6-2T  ( and  its  been  a  long 4+ years!) may be interested to  know  that  I have  just  received  an eMail  from  Heljan.dk  advising  me  that  the  loco  will be  arriving on our  shores     Late March  Early  April.

I am currently in  the  process  of  building  a L&B  'based' layout in a  garden  shed,   got  most  of  the  rolling  stock, just  need  the  locos  so  I  can  return  the   Roco H0e locos  to  their  rightful  layout!!
Title: Re: Lynton & Barnstaple 2-6-2T from Heljan
Post by: B.Meldon on February 21, 2017, 10:35
The news from Peco at the weekend was that the consignment had been packed into a container about a month ago and that it was on its way to the UK.

The example on display at Shepton Mallet on the Peco stand was one of the first locos off the full production line, it even came in the full production box with instructions etc.

I have to say that in my own and the opinion of many others it is as near to perfect as any model of this loco could be in our chosen scale.
I doubt that even the best modellers could produce an equal or better example from a kit or scratch built.

It is easily the same if not better quality than the Bemo H0e products, but at a quarter of the price!

We were told that the final delay in shipping the locos was caused by assembly problems in the factory not any design issues.

I am very glad to say that demand has exceeded all expectations and the first production run is somewhat oversubscribed by retailers. As a result it is thought, but in no way official, that they are going to be rationed out between the retailers. Although this may not be the case if this happens it is possible that sadly some with pre-orders may be disappointed, but this is just conjecture. However a second batch is already planned.

Brian Meldon


Title: Re: Lynton & Barnstaple 2-6-2T from Heljan
Post by: Steve Lewis on February 21, 2017, 11:45
Re  the   supply  situation,  I have  spoken  to   a few  retailers  with   Locos  on  order  who  advise  me  that  their  presell orders    do leave  quite  a lot  of   'unspoken for  locos'

I also believe  that  the  production locos  which   were not ordered by Heljan retail customers  will be   wholesaled  by PECO  thus  the non Heljan Account  customers  will be  able  to obtain  stock  should  they  wish.

_________________________________________________________________


What  chance  'LYN'  I wonder,  in  reality  probably  very  little,  but  as  LYN  was  a  production loco  from Baldwin in the  USA  and therefore  it  would  have  been  sold  elsewhere  there  is  the  small possibility  that  NON L&B followers  may be  interested

It  should be  considered  that  Bachmann  produced  their  G  Scale  example  as  LYN  but  also made  it  available  in  Black livery,  which apparently  outsold  Lyn  in  the  USA.
Title: Re: Lynton & Barnstaple 2-6-2T from Heljan
Post by: B.Meldon on February 21, 2017, 14:02
Bachmann USA and Bachmann UK (or Europe) have no links they operate as separate companies. Thomas locos apart it is doubtful that Bachmann USA would be interested in a 009 product as their market in the US is for H0 scale.

The Bachmann UK 009 WD Baldwin 4-6-0 has now been given a December 2018 delivery date and I do wonder if we will ever see it, so the chances of another 009 loco from them this decade is highly unlikely.

Heljan will produce all the L&B variations in names and liveries using the cab design they already have before producing the alternative cab versions (i.e. Lew and possibly even Lyd?)It is unlikely that we will get a freelance livery as the original L&B livery has no identifying marks so will do that job quite well anyway.

Only then will they consider another 009 loco, so again unlikely this decade!

Brian Meldon
Title: Re: Lynton & Barnstaple 2-6-2T from Heljan
Post by: Steve Lewis on February 21, 2017, 14:10
Having  been  in  this  hobby  for  around  60 years  I  am  aware   that  Bachmann  US  &   EU   are  separate  divisions  of  Kader  industries!

The  Baldwin  4-6-0  delivery  date  has  been  amended  to  DEC 2017  ( Unless  of  course  it  has  been  re  amended  to  2018!!) and  apparently  work  on  it  is  progressing. It  has  been  signed  off to  proceed to   the   tooling  stage .

 Incidentally  the  Bachmann 009 rolling  stock    is  listed  as  SEPT/OCT  delivery

The  point  I was  making  re  LYN  is  that  it   was  not  a  ONE OFF  as  many  think  and  that  other  modellers  could  perhaps  be  interested in other  liveries  for  their   freelance  layouts.
Title: Re: Lynton & Barnstaple 2-6-2T from Heljan
Post by: rod335 on February 21, 2017, 15:10
My understanding is that Heljan DO have another 009 loco in development as well as Lew/Lyd. But they are very tight-lipped about its identity.
Title: Re: Lynton & Barnstaple 2-6-2T from Heljan
Post by: Steve Lewis on February 21, 2017, 15:38
Quote from: rod335 on February 21, 2017, 15:10
My understanding is that Heljan DO have another 009 loco in development as well as Lew/Lyd. But they are very tight-lipped about its identity.


Interesting    Remember  the  Cancelled  ROCO project  for  the  Ffestiniog  Double  Fairlie,  I wonder  how  far that  was  actually progressed?

Hint  Hint  say no more,  know  what  I  mean!!

Or perhaps  not!
Title: Re: Lynton & Barnstaple 2-6-2T from Heljan
Post by: B.Meldon on February 21, 2017, 15:59
Quote from: Steve Lewis on February 21, 2017, 14:10
Having  been  in  this  hobby  for  around  60 years  I  am  aware   that  Bachmann  US  &   EU   are  separate  divisions  of  Kader  industries!

No insult intended Steve!

Quote from: Steve Lewis on February 21, 2017, 14:10

The  Baldwin  4-6-0  delivery  date  has  been  amended  to  DEC 2017  ( Unless  of  course  it  has  been  re  amended  to  2018!!) and  apparently  work  on  it  is  progressing. It  has  been  signed  off to  proceed to   the   tooling  stage .


Perhaps someone should tell Parkside Dundas as they are still listing a Dec 2018 date for the 4-6-0's:

http://www.parksidedundas.co.uk/acatalog/copy_of_Steam_Locomotives.html

Also  for  some  reason  there  are  double  spaces  between  almost  all  the  words  in  all  your  posts  Steve!
(But  you  may  know  that  as  well   and   it  could  be  deliberate  for  some  reason??)

Brian Meldon
Title: Re: Lynton & Barnstaple 2-6-2T from Heljan
Post by: B.Meldon on February 21, 2017, 16:10
Quote from: rod335 on February 21, 2017, 15:10
My understanding is that Heljan DO have another 009 loco in development as well as Lew/Lyd. But they are very tight-lipped about its identity.

I am sure there are others that know what loco has been measured and photographed by Heljan.
But if the timescale for the L&B loco is anything to go by then it is over three years away from production. So not in this decade!

Brian Meldon
Title: Re: Lynton & Barnstaple 2-6-2T from Heljan
Post by: Steve Lewis on February 21, 2017, 16:36
Not  sure  why  the  double  spaces occur!

It  does  not  occur  on  anything  else  I am  using  today  ( work wise!  and  009 track  layin'  and  pulling  up  garden  line  between  the  Welsh  Rain!)
But  I  will check  it  later**

The  Baldwin 2018 date  occurred  round  about  the  time  of  the  Bachmann  Presentation in Jan  but  it  was apparently a  misprint, but  it did  result  in  much  wringing   of  hands  & Gnashing  of  teeth  on  some  forums!

**I think  I may  have  sorted  the  double  spacing  Already!!
Title: Re: Lynton & Barnstaple 2-6-2T from Heljan
Post by: Andrew Emery on February 21, 2017, 19:02
Quote from: Steve Lewis on February 21, 2017, 14:10
Having  been  in  this  hobby  for  around  60 years  I  am  aware   that  Bachmann  US  &   EU   are  separate  divisions  of  Kader  industries

I didn't know, and I am sure a lot if others didn't know either. Thanks for the info Brian.


Title: Re: Lynton & Barnstaple 2-6-2T from Heljan
Post by: Steve Lewis on February 21, 2017, 19:07
Kader  industries  don't  just  make  Model  railways!  They  have  extensive  manufacturing facilities apparently  for  making all sortd of  consumer  goods  items,  worth  a  look  at  their  website(s)

sorry  to  digress  off topic!
Title: Re: Lynton & Barnstaple 2-6-2T from Heljan
Post by: Steve Lewis on March 29, 2017, 19:00
I  sent  an  eMail  to  Heljan DK  today  to  request  info  regarding  availability  of  the  Manning  Wardle  Loco

They  replied  advising  that  an  Official  announcement  is to  be  made  late  next  week  regarding deliveries, and  that  currently  they  ( Heljan Staff) are  in  China and  checking   production  which  they  stated  as  being  very  good.

So we  will know  more  next  week  I  guess.
Title: Re: Lynton & Barnstaple 2-6-2T from Heljan
Post by: Stan Williams on March 30, 2017, 17:44
I had a message today that Hattons are increasing the MW Heljan loco to
Title: Re: Lynton & Barnstaple 2-6-2T from Heljan
Post by: Steve Lewis on March 30, 2017, 18:04
Yes  Hattons  only  have  2  variants  on presell now the  third  being  fully  subscribed  , so now  Hattons  are  seeking  to  maximise their profitability by   increasing  the  price  to  the  RRP.

Derails  Models (they  have  a  website) are  still listing  their 
Title: Re: Lynton & Barnstaple 2-6-2T from Heljan
Post by: Steve Lewis on April 02, 2017, 09:17
Derails   Models  pre  sell  all   spoken  for  now

Some  other  outlets  are  getting  close  to  closing  their  pre sells
Title: Re: Lynton & Barnstaple 2-6-2T from Heljan
Post by: Steve Lewis on April 05, 2017, 19:05
NEW DELIVERY  DATES!!

First  Batch   MID to    END  MAY  followed  by  a  2nd  delivery  END JUNE   Heljan  have  said  they  are producing a  further  batch to be  delivered  end  August  but  the  price  will show   an increase on this  batch.

Title: Re: Lynton & Barnstaple 2-6-2T from Heljan
Post by: Pete Williams on April 20, 2017, 01:10
Quote from: Steve Lewis on February 21, 2017, 09:18
Members  who  are  awaiting  the  arrival  of  the  L&B 2-6-2T  ( and  its  been  a  long 4+ years!) may be interested to  know  that  I have  just  received  an eMail  from  Heljan.dk  advising  me  that  the  loco  will be  arriving on our  shores     Late March  Early  April.

I am currently in  the  process  of  building  a L&B  'based' layout in a  garden  shed,   got  most  of  the  rolling  stock, just  need  the  locos  so  I  can  return  the   Roco H0e locos  to  their  rightful  layout!!
Delivery must be by return working of that first goods train that is taking seventeen days to reach china.
I read on the 'net' that the delivery date has been put back ( yet again), to mid -late may.
What's that song? So tired, tired of waiting, tired of waiting for yoo-oo!
Title: Re: Lynton & Barnstaple 2-6-2T from Heljan
Post by: Steve Lewis on April 20, 2017, 21:32
As  A  result  of  an  email  from  Heljan.dk  I reprted  on  APRIL 5th  the  revised 'provisional' delivery  dates  of  MAY (MID)  and  June  for  the  first  batch  and   a  further  delivery  of  a  second  batch different  versions  (see RM Advert  May 17 full page  Heljan)  at  the  year  end apparently,  the  2nd  batch  will have  4  variants as  noted  in the Railway Modeller May  advert  and  also  showing on  Hattons  web site

The  first  batch  is  completely  sold  out  out  and  many  UK  retailers  have pre sold  their  stock,  so  the  loco  will be  probably  hard  to  actually  purchase  if  not  pre ordered.

The  2nd  batch  will be  at  a  higher  price  ( understandable)  as  it  has  been  over  4  years  since  initial RRP  of  189.99 was  set  and  many  things   have  changed/changing  in  the  financial  world.

in  the  meantime  we  will just  have  to  make  sure   the  axle  boxes  on  our  Peco  L&B rolling  stock  is  well lubricated  in  readiness  for  the  actual  arrival  of  the  2-6-2T  ( And  I  can  sell off my  MINITRAINS 2-6-2 & 0-8-0 locos!!)

Title: Re: Lynton & Barnstaple 2-6-2T from Heljan
Post by: Steve Lewis on May 18, 2017, 17:12
Latest  delivery info  I received  from  Heljan  today:

Part of  the  first  production run  should  arrive  LATE  May/  Early  June  followed  by the  remainder   in June or  July

Hope this  info is  useful

A little more  time  to  save  up  perhaps!! :)
Title: Re: Lynton & Barnstaple 2-6-2T from Heljan
Post by: Steve Lewis on June 08, 2017, 12:31
Heljan  advise  me  the  first  420  locos  are  on  their  way  as  of  today  to  UK  retailers,  but   this  is  only  a  proportion  of  the  production  run  so  apparently  not all orders  will be  fully  fulfilled,  more  stock  will be  sent  in  July  &  August.

( My retailer  advised  me  that as  far  as  he  is  aware  TAW is  not  in  the  first  420)
Title: Re: Lynton & Barnstaple 2-6-2T from Heljan
Post by: Pete Williams on June 10, 2017, 14:33
Invicta appear to have dropped the loco from their webpage, i have just ordered the 9950 version from hattons ( the chip arrived yesterday !?) expected delivery date is now estimated as late June-mid July.
Title: Re: Lynton & Barnstaple 2-6-2T from Heljan
Post by: Steve Lewis on June 10, 2017, 14:48
As  of  today  the  locos  have  started  arriving  in  the  retailers,  my 2 initial ones  should arrive in  the  post  early  next  week  ( TAW is not  yet  delivered to  Heljan that  will be apparently  July)

There  is  a  post on rmweb  forum   in  the  Heljan  section  (L&B Loco)  posted  this  morning of   a loco  getting  its  initial test on a  layout.

The  problem  will be  that  most of  the  retailers have  pre sold  all their  allocation.

I am  aware  of a  retailer  that  'may' have  a  couple  spare  PM me  for  info.
Title: Re: Lynton & Barnstaple 2-6-2T from Heljan
Post by: Steve Lewis on June 13, 2017, 15:03
  2  of  my  L&B  Locos  arrived  today,  to  save  retyping  my  personal initial  review  can  I  refer   members  to www.rmweb.co.uk  forum  Heljan  section.

My findings  so  far  are  not  quite living  up to  expectations  yet!

And now  even  less enthusiastic about .... them   valve  gear  problem,  its  come  apart on 1  side!...  more to follow!
Title: Re: Lynton & Barnstaple 2-6-2T from Heljan
Post by: Jon Baker on June 15, 2017, 13:27
Quote from: Steve Lewis on June 13, 2017, 15:03
 2  of  my  L&B  Locos  arrived  today,  to  save  retyping  my  personal initial  review  can  I  refer   members  to www.rmweb.co.uk  forum  Heljan  section.
My findings  so  far  are  not  quite living  up to  expectations  yet!
Received Exe yesterday, test running today on simple oval (Peco Setrack). Runs perfectly when turning left (in forward direction) but will not turn right in forward direction (or left in reverse). Issue seems to be with the pony truck (as you have mentioned on the RMweb forum). With pony truck derailed loco runs perfectly well :-)
Disappointing.
Title: Re: Lynton & Barnstaple 2-6-2T from Heljan
Post by: Steve Lewis on June 15, 2017, 14:00
On  Narrow  Gauge Railway  Modelling   forum  today a member  has  reported  valve  gear  problems  and   a  nameplate  fell off!

Its  not  good  news  at  all  ,  I probably  will not   get  my  loco  replaced  for  several  weeks  now  and  if   the  problems mount  up  it  is  likely  that  Heljan  will not  release  further  stock  until   the  problem(s)  are  sorted  out.

Re  the pony  trucks,, I do believe that  the  strange  power collection  method  ( Brass strips springing  down on to  the  tops of  the   wheels)
is  causing  the  pony trucks be  unable  to  swing  freely  to  follow  the  track  curves thus  causing derailment, when  the loco  reaches  a  point it  shorts out or  jams  up  completely  on  the  frog  or  check rail

I removed  the  ponies  and  ran  the  loco as  an 0-6-0  and  all was  well  no problems with power  collection,  the   driving wheel base  is around 4mm longer  than  a Minitrains 0-8-0  and  whereas  the  0-8-0  weighs  74gm  the  L&B  weighs 139gm,   removing  the  brass pickup pieces  may be  on option?
Also be  aware  the  Valve  gear  covers seem to be  just  a  push on  fit  they  tend  to  fall off!
Title: Re: Lynton & Barnstaple 2-6-2T from Heljan
Post by: Jon Baker on June 15, 2017, 14:49
Quote from: Steve Lewis on June 15, 2017, 14:00

I removed  the  ponies  and  ran  the  loco as  an 0-6-0  and  all was  well  no problems with power  collection,  the   driving wheel base  is around 4mm longer  than  a Minitrains 0-8-0  and  whereas  the  0-8-0  weighs  74gm  the  L&B  weighs 139gm,   removing  the  brass pickup pieces  may be  on option?
On mine one of the pickups on the rear is not flat to the base of the loco like the other one, I suspect the springiness of this individual pickup is at least contributing to the problem (it coincides with the turn direction). Maybe removing these pickups altogether is the answer, but disappointed that the quality is poor necessitating this.
Title: Re: Lynton & Barnstaple 2-6-2T from Heljan
Post by: Ian James on June 15, 2017, 16:54
I received my Yeo today, and so far I am very disappointed after such a long wait. I have been building a layout for it, using Peco 009 track. The loco shorts and derails on the pointwork. The couplings will not connect to Peco coaches or wagons. I also have many loading gauge problems - the cylinders foul the platform edges I had carefully installed using PEco coaches to get the clearances right. Part of the problem with points may be the cylinders fouling the little pips on the tie bar of Peco points. I had understood that Heljan and Peco had been liaising on the development of these models to ensure compatibility. If so, the collaboration seems not to have worked.
Title: Re: Lynton & Barnstaple 2-6-2T from Heljan
Post by: Steve Lewis on June 15, 2017, 22:51
There  have  been  several  posts  made   by purchasers of  this  loco  on  other  websites  also  reporting  problems  ( Rmweb  & Narrow Gauge Railway Modelling)  it  is  all very disappointing  considering  that  many of  us  have  invested   our  time  & money during  the almost 4.5 years  since  the loco was  first announced purchasing  Peco  rolling  stock  in  good  faith  expecting  to  eventually get  motive power  that performs well.
Title: Re: Lynton & Barnstaple 2-6-2T from Heljan
Post by: Ian James on June 16, 2017, 15:28
I have just been reminding myself of the rave review of these locos in the April 2017 Railway Modeller. They extol the consistency with Peco 009 track and points, and say that the couplings are consistent with the Peco rolling stock - the couplings, they say "ensure a perfect match". I can only assume that the reviewer simply looked at the model in the box and did not actually run it on a real layout or attempt to couple it to Peco rolling stock.

My Yeo is a superb static display item in a siding on my layout, but useless to run and haul trains. One would urge the model railway press to be a bit more thorough and penetrating in their reviews, rather than simply providing uncritical advertising for manufacturers of poorly designed products.
Title: Re: Lynton & Barnstaple 2-6-2T from Heljan
Post by: Steve Lewis on June 16, 2017, 16:15
Quote from: Ian James on June 16, 2017, 15:28
I have just been reminding myself of the rave review of these locos in the April 2017 Railway Modeller. They extol the consistency with Peco 009 track and points, and say that the couplings are consistent with the Peco rolling stock - the couplings, they say "ensure a perfect match". I can only assume that the reviewer simply looked at the model in the box and did not actually run it on a real layout or attempt to couple it to Peco rolling stock.

My Yeo is a superb static display item in a siding on my layout, but useless to run and haul trains. One would urge the model railway press to be a bit more thorough and penetrating in their reviews, rather than simply providing uncritical advertising for manufacturers of poorly designed products.

Hi  Ian    do  you  look  at  rmweb forum  there  is  quite  a  bit  on  there  re  the  Heljan  problems  (in the Heljan  section) may be  worth  a  look  and posting  your comments  as  I am  aware that some  manfrs  do  look/
Title: Re: Lynton & Barnstaple 2-6-2T from Heljan
Post by: DeadHorse on June 16, 2017, 16:40
I couldnt agree with you more Ian. If a model is submitted for public criticism then that is what it should get.
Heaping praise upon something that simply doesnt deserve it doesnt do anybody any favours.
I often think of that when I see a members model/layout/latest concoction so often being lauded within these very pages as 'magnificent' 'so lifelike' 'great modelling' etc when really it deserves a 'good effort, but ......' at most.
My own modelling skills are nowhere near good enough for public viewing and I am in awe of many contributors on here, even if I dont care for their chosen subject matter, but to ignore the many mistakes made by beginners that seem obvious to us is not doing them any favours either.
Please - can we steer folks in the right direction instead of just letting them carry on making their own mistakes until they get fed up and give up.
Title: Re: Lynton & Barnstaple 2-6-2T from Heljan
Post by: Steve Lewis on June 16, 2017, 18:06
It will be  interesting  to  see what  if  any reviews  or  follow  up comments  appear  in  which magazines now  that  the locos  are  becoming  available,  I bet  there  is  a  stony  silence  from  PECO /RM!
Title: Re: Lynton & Barnstaple 2-6-2T from Heljan
Post by: Steve Lewis on June 21, 2017, 13:04
For   information  I  have  just  returned  my  2  to  the  retailer!
Title: Re: Lynton & Barnstaple 2-6-2T from Heljan
Post by: Steve Lewis on June 25, 2017, 09:58
For   further  info,  on  the   Manning   Wardle  saga

I had  info  from a  purchaser ( who  makes  some interesting  L&B related  items,  wagon  loads,  bridges, small buildings etc and  sells them on ebay) whose  Loco failed  with  broken  valve  gear  after  under  1  hours  running  time  and  also  a  friend  of  his  who had also bought a loco had  the  same  failure  almost immediately it  wwas  first  run.

my supplying retailer told me  yesterday  that  of  the 8 he  has  had delivered to  date, my 2  have  failed  and   another 1  has  reported  valve gear problems  and  2  have  yet  to be collected.

I would  advise  that  if  anyone  has one  they  have  not  yet  tested,  they do so as  soon  as  possible as  I can see  there being  a  bit   of  a  waiting  list  for  replacements.
Title: Re: Lynton & Barnstaple 2-6-2T from Heljan
Post by: Pete Williams on July 15, 2017, 16:43
Ah - could all this be the reason for the stony silence in the modelling press? - only statement in this month's Railway Modeller (page 716)  is a short announcement that the models have arrived with retailers in early june.
Not even a sniff of a review mentioned as forthcoming in next month's issue.
I'm seriously considering cancelling my not-yet-arrived pre order.
Can anyone tell me if the recommended bachmann dcc chip will fit roco's bo-bo electric ?
Title: Re: Lynton & Barnstaple 2-6-2T from Heljan
Post by: Pete Williams on October 02, 2017, 11:40
Just returned mine.
Link pin on the left hand side, just behind the cylinder, was never fitted into it's socket on the chassis.
Definate lack of quality control at the factory.
Title: Re: Lynton & Barnstaple 2-6-2T from Heljan
Post by: B.Meldon on October 02, 2017, 12:46
Yes it is all very sad!
My understanding is that Heljan intend to use a different manufacturer for future batches.
Exactly how this will work out regarding moulding dies etc. I have no idea, but I guess that Heljan own them??

Brian Meldon
Title: Re: Lynton & Barnstaple 2-6-2T from Heljan
Post by: Pete Williams on October 09, 2017, 12:06
I have just received a reply from Heljan UK regarding my complaint about poor quality. They say that they have cancelled the contract with the previous company and have a new supply for the next batch and assure me that the quality will be much improved. In good faith, i have placed my pre-order today.
Title: Re: Lynton & Barnstaple 2-6-2T from Heljan
Post by: B.Meldon on October 09, 2017, 12:18
Quote from: Pete Williams on October 09, 2017, 12:06
I have just received a reply from Heljan UK regarding my complaint about poor quality. They say that they have cancelled the contract with the previous company and have a new supply for the next batch and assure me that the quality will be much improved. In good faith, i have placed my pre-order today.

Did they give you any dates for the next batch?

Brian Meldon
Title: Re: Lynton & Barnstaple 2-6-2T from Heljan
Post by: Tom Haythornthwaite on October 09, 2017, 20:53
I was just about to cancel.  Hm, now, what to do?
Title: Re: Lynton & Barnstaple 2-6-2T from Heljan
Post by: Hobby on October 10, 2017, 11:38
Let someone else try them first... ;)
Title: Re: Lynton & Barnstaple 2-6-2T from Heljan
Post by: Tom Haythornthwaite on October 17, 2017, 17:32
"Let someone else try them first... Wink"

Ha!  Very wise!

Meanwhile, can anybody tell me (sorry if this hasn't been covered before) how the 2-6-2T ended up doing on 9" radius curves?

Title: Re: Lynton & Barnstaple 2-6-2T from Heljan
Post by: Pete Williams on December 18, 2017, 22:44
Latest delivery date feb-march 2018 (suposedly )
Bachmans due may.
Title: Re: Lynton & Barnstaple 2-6-2T from Heljan
Post by: Michael Melton on February 16, 2018, 15:26
Are these able to run on 9" curves? 

I've read many contradicting views on this.  Some say it makes it if driven carefully, some say it doesn't make it. 

I would like to get one, but my layout is tight as it is. 
Title: Re: Lynton & Barnstaple 2-6-2T from Heljan
Post by: Paulc on February 20, 2018, 17:33
From my personal experience; sometimes!

I set up an oval of Peco set track to use for running in, testing etc.  The loco ran through it OK.  A bit "squeaky" on one curve.  I decided to put a couple of set track points in initially to see how the dead frog affected running.  The 2-6-2 does not like them and de rails most of the time.  I tried slackening off the "end" wheels which made it slightly better (Someone may have posted on this?) but it still does not like the points, de railing about 30% of the time.  It is now also stopping on one section of the curved track and I can't see why.  I haven't pinned the track yet as I'm thinking of making the test track a small scenic layout so it may be that it was slightly uneven. Although the weight of the 2-6-2 compared to the Minitrains Bagnall pushes the track quite heavily down on the base  (Cork laid on flat ply)

Sorry if a "sometimes" answer isn't much help, but that's my experience.  The Minitrains Bagnall,and other Minitrains locos however go throught the curves and the pointwork at impressively slow speeds without problem.
Title: Re: Lynton & Barnstaple 2-6-2T from Heljan
Post by: James Mackeown on February 20, 2018, 18:42
I have perhaps a different perspective on the Heljan lynton and Barnstaple as,
on finding the running somewhat haphazard, I dismantled and fitted RC (it's a bad habit I have) in one of the two locos I have. Not an easy task...
This gave me the opportunity to see how the loco ran without relying on rail pick up.
Firstly the valve gear has a peculiar habit of jamming, just a small amount but needed adjusting. The motor itself sits poorly and tends to run free from the gearing if the screws beneath are not tightened correctly. I suspect stripped gears could result.
The main cause (only cause in my case) of derailment is from the front and rear bogies. (please excuse any errors in English as after 30 years in France I get rusty) ...
The solution for me as I no longer rely on electrical pickup was to modify the pressure on the front and rear axles so that they are free to curve round the tighter points. It works.
But it should work out of the box and it's truly a shame that it, and apparently many others, didn't.
Regards
James
Title: Re: Lynton & Barnstaple 2-6-2T from Heljan
Post by: B.Meldon on February 21, 2018, 10:42
Having now had a look at the locos with others we think the main problem with the bogies is that the axles are a lose fit in the bogie frame.
This can and does result in the wheels sitting at the wrong angle to the rails and can result in derailments at points.
What they need to do is to make the axles fit in the bogies with minimal movement (including side to side movement) with any movement required (left, right, up and down etc.) taking place in the bogie pivot only, thus keeping the wheels at the correct angle to the rails.
The contacts that press down on the bogie wheels are unnecessary in my opinion and should be removed leaving just six wheel pickup. However this will require the plastic bogie frames to be heavier and replaced with cast metal ones so that the weight of the bogie frame will be enough to keep the wheel on the track.
But this is just my assessment, so others may think differently.
I have not had a look at the valve gear or the motor.

Brian Meldon
Title: Re: Lynton & Barnstaple 2-6-2T from Heljan
Post by: Michael Melton on February 21, 2018, 14:42
Quote from: Paulc on February 20, 2018, 17:33
From my personal experience; sometimes!

I set up an oval of Peco set track to use for running in, testing etc.  The loco ran through it OK.  A bit "squeaky" on one curve.  I decided to put a couple of set track points in initially to see how the dead frog affected running.  The 2-6-2 does not like them and de rails most of the time.  I tried slackening off the "end" wheels which made it slightly better (Someone may have posted on this?) but it still does not like the points, de railing about 30% of the time.  It is now also stopping on one section of the curved track and I can't see why.  I haven't pinned the track yet as I'm thinking of making the test track a small scenic layout so it may be that it was slightly uneven. Although the weight of the 2-6-2 compared to the Minitrains Bagnall pushes the track quite heavily down on the base  (Cork laid on flat ply)

Sorry if a "sometimes" answer isn't much help, but that's my experience.  The Minitrains Bagnall,and other Minitrains locos however go throught the curves and the pointwork at impressively slow speeds without problem.

That is a shame.  They look so nice.  I have limited space and already bought PECO setrack.  Had I known, I'd might of went the ROCO way with my track. 
Title: Re: Lynton & Barnstaple 2-6-2T from Heljan
Post by: Tom Haythornthwaite on February 21, 2018, 18:35
This is so discouraging.  I am still in the queue for my example from Hatton's.  Didn't we once understand that the second batch was being made by a different Chinese company and / with much better quality assurance?  (I don't know when or where I read this.)  But a lot of what I'm reading now sounds like design problems rather than build quality. 

I have a Fourdees Bagnall being chipped for DCC and I am so so close to cancelling my Heljan 2-6-2.  Anything I run will be pretending to have shown up in India so it doesn't have to be authentically this or that....

Thoughts on a postcard.

Title: Re: Lynton & Barnstaple 2-6-2T from Heljan
Post by: Hobby on February 21, 2018, 18:51
I'm sure they did say they were using a different factory and that the "issues" would be sorted. I would wait and see, if they turn out to be rubbish you'll get your money back just as those who have had problems have this time, so you can't lose either way. Just be patient and wait...
Title: Re: Lynton & Barnstaple 2-6-2T from Heljan
Post by: JulienW on February 22, 2018, 10:27
I was chatting to someone at the 2017 Welshpool gala who had 2 of the L&B 2-6-2s running around an oval of Peco 009 set track over the weekend with no obvious problems. I recall that he suggested that Heljan had also had quality issues with their Chinese-built OO stuff - things not being located properly and the like - that seem to be similar to issues with the 009 locos.

I also have a feeling that he had bought his via Peco, and specking to someone at Peco prior to the release of the L&B locos he told me that every one they were selling on was going to be unboxed, track tested and repacked before sending off to the final customer.  This seemed a little extreme at the time but in hindsight perhaps not such a bad idea after all, and I wonder what their 'return rate' was and if there was a particular variant that had more issues than others...

I don't think that the second batch from the new factory have arrived on the scene yet as I imagine it will take Heljan a bit of time to move the tooling to the new site and train staff to do the work (properly this time!).

@Tom perhaps a better bet would be the Bachmann 4-6-0 WD Baldwin as several of these went to India, admittedly for use in industry afaik but you could get away with them on a common carrier.
Title: Re: Lynton & Barnstaple 2-6-2T from Heljan
Post by: B.Meldon on February 22, 2018, 10:59
From what I have been told the next batch will have all new tooling!!
Heljan have the drawings and software details etc. to produce new tooling but the original tooling will remain with the original manufacture in China!
Obviously if this is correct, and I have no reason to doubt it, this will not be cheap for Heljan and it will not be a quick process either.

It has been mentioned that the cost of the new tooling may be offset by the number of the first batch locos returned to the manufacture. But this is pure conjecture.

Not everyone has had problems with these locos so as a comparison and to be fair to the product if you have one and have been using it without any problems please do post on this topic and let us all know.

Brian Meldon
Title: Re: Lynton & Barnstaple 2-6-2T from Heljan
Post by: stevebar on February 28, 2018, 17:52
Hi guys. This is my first post, having been a member for a few months I finally got round to registering.
My wife was kind enough to buy one of these for me towards the end of last year. It ran nicely. But the couplings were mounted at such an angle that it wouldn't couple to any rolling stock. In view of the noise they'd made along the lines of "in conjunction with Peco" I found this astounding as said stock was Peco RTR stuff. So, phone call to retailer, not happy with response of "you'll have to talk to Heljan",  "sorry pal, you're the retailer". I was also told that I wasn't the first to report this problem.
Straight back in post for refund as "not fit for purpose".     
How can a major manufacturer justify sending items out that are simply not up to standard?
Title: Re: Lynton & Barnstaple 2-6-2T from Heljan
Post by: JulienW on February 28, 2018, 22:11
My feeling is that the problem is that with Heljan being based somewhere in Europe (can't recall where) and the locos being produced in China whoever is responsible for quality control at Heljan can't just "pop down to the shop floor and do a spot check", as doing so involves getting on a plane and (probably) involves getting a visa to get into the country so I suspect that the factory know that the QC guy is on his way so that they can get things in order and do things properly when he arrives rather than continuing with the slap dash way they were doing it to maximise their own profits. One of the issues raised with the Heljan locos has been that it appears that the incorrect adhesives have been used - a cheaper superglue than a 'loctite' retaining compound for example.

To be fair to Heljan they didn't realise there was a problem until customers started returning them to the retailers who then returned them to Heljan. Once they realised there were problems they must have looked into the issues and on investigation have decided to stop production, and have announced a redesign the chassis - presumably to make the assembly easier (or less prone to being cocked up!).

It does seem a bit odd though that some retailers still seem to be selling them when you'd have thought that Heljan would have recalled the defective locos - though I wonder how many of those currently on sale are being sold (on eBay?) by people trying to cash in on their 'rarity value' as you can't get them in the shops anymore...
Title: Re: Lynton & Barnstaple 2-6-2T from Heljan
Post by: Pete Williams on March 01, 2018, 15:49
I can only relate my experience, regarding the short time that i owned one, before it was returned to the retailer for a refund.
I repeat:-
It ran purfectly during testing, it was only when i examined the valve gear, using a magmifying glass that i saw that the valve gear had never been assembled correctly, one of the triangular headed motion pins had never been inserted into it's mounting in the chassis, and was wedged in place behind the cylinder.
On further examination,
I also found thet the threads on the bolts that the pony trucks pivoted on, were either stripped by overtightening during assembley or tapped oversize With the possiblity of the bolt falling out.
I did email Heljan UK and receved assurances by return that the contract with the then chinese manufacturer had been ended and a new manufacturer employed. On the re-assurance that quality control will be improved, i have ordered a 9955 , Rails of Sheffield say that they expect deliveries towards the end of the month.
Title: Re: Lynton & Barnstaple 2-6-2T from Heljan
Post by: Ed Kilby on March 12, 2018, 14:21
Have some of these been released already, i see they're available for pre order, is this another delayed project or have they already released some that have sold out and are now awaiting another batch?

Interested as i have pre ordered some from my local shop who seems to think there is a delay until next year from what Heljan told him but hattons have a release date of may 2018.

Anyone know anything more?

Sorry to make it a little more obvious i am talking about ones with the southern livery

Title: Re: Lynton & Barnstaple 2-6-2T from Heljan
Post by: Michael Melton on March 13, 2018, 13:17
I know that there was a first batch, as I thought the same thing seeing a few on Youtube and eBay.  The first batch had issues with the valve gear coming apart.  They switched manufacturers and they recently updated the release to be May 2018 (it was March).
Title: Re: Lynton & Barnstaple 2-6-2T from Heljan
Post by: B.Meldon on March 13, 2018, 15:27
Quote from: M.Melton on March 13, 2018, 13:17
I know that there was a first batch, as I thought the same thing seeing a few on Youtube and eBay.  The first batch had issues with the valve gear coming apart.  They switched manufacturers and they recently updated the release to be May 2018 (it was March).
The second batch have not been made yet.
All the examples you see for sale now are from the first batch.

Brian Meldon

Title: Re: Lynton & Barnstaple 2-6-2T from Heljan
Post by: Ed Kilby on March 13, 2018, 19:11
I see on the hattons website that they have pre orders due for release in may? are these batch one or two? or is this just to entice you to pre order and then they will push the date back until they're actually released
Title: Re: Lynton & Barnstaple 2-6-2T from Heljan
Post by: Chris Harvey on March 17, 2018, 09:11
I believe the answer is that the models from both the originally announced versions and the subsequently announced variations of the original three L&B Manning Wardles will arrive at the same time. Heljan have stated that they have switched factory for this production.

Chris H
Title: Re: Lynton & Barnstaple 2-6-2T from Heljan
Post by: Tom Haythornthwaite on April 12, 2018, 07:38
I've just cancelled my order (from Hatten's).  I've just received my Fourdees WG Bagnall - Bowater and it's everything I want in a loco.
Title: Re: Lynton & Barnstaple 2-6-2T from Heljan
Post by: Michael Melton on April 19, 2018, 19:21
Just got an email from Hattons:


QuoteProject Updates
All the latest news on up and coming releases!

Heljan OO9 Narrow Gauge - Lynton and Barnstaple locomotives
Heljan have provided us with a number of updates regarding their forthcoming Lynton and Barnstaple locomotives.

Batch 1 - Product Codes 9950 to 9956

We have been informed that revised samples of all above models have been received, tested and approved by Heljan allowing production of these models to commence, with delivery expected in September 2018.

We have a limited amount of these models remaining available to pre-order.

Batch 2 - Product Codes 9960 to 9963

Heljan have confirmed that models of Nos. 188 "Lew" and No.190 "Lyd" are also to be produced, with delivery expected in early 2019. These are now available to pre-order via the link below.

To see more images and for further product information, visit:
Heljan OO9 Lynton and Barnstaple
As soon as we have any further updates on the progress of this model, we'll be in touch! However, don't hesitate to contact us in the meantime if you have any queries.


Just in case anyone on here wanted to know.
Title: Re: Lynton & Barnstaple 2-6-2T from Heljan
Post by: Pete Williams on June 29, 2018, 12:39
Advised by hattons will be in stock (first batch ) in september
One advertiser offering pre-orders at a eye watering
Title: Re: Lynton & Barnstaple 2-6-2T from Heljan
Post by: S Wilkinson on January 21, 2026, 09:09
I recently bought one from Footplate and I haven't tried it yet (I've not built a layout yet) - I'm hoping it's from batch 2!

I was wondering how wide a loop would need to be to run safely please?

Any points would be mainline rather than short to hopefully ease the issues there too.

Any advice would be appreciated.